Retrieval of a Lane Plate 82 Years After Implantation: Case Report, Metallurgical Analysis, and Historical Review.

BACKGROUND

The Lane plate was one of the first widely used bone plates, utilized in the first decades of the twentieth century. Here we present the results of a retrieval analysis on a Lane plate, and a review of the history of these plates. Our patient underwent plating of her femur with a Lane plate in 1938. She developed a sciatic nerve palsy, managed surgically later that year by Dr. Arthur Steindler at the University of Iowa. Her femur healed, her nerve recovered, and she did well until 2020, at age 94, when she presented to the University of Iowa with a draining sinus that appeared to communicate with the plate. She underwent irrigation and debridement with hardware removal. The plate was sectioned, and its composition and structure characterized.

METHODS

We retrieved hard copies of the patient's archived medical records from 1938, which document in detail the treatments performed by Dr. Steindler. The plate was analyzed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to characterize the surface of the plate. A cross section was taken from the plate, and the composition of the alloy was determined using energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS). A review of the literature surrounding early plating techniques was conducted.

RESULTS

Our patient recovered from her surgery and soon returned to her baseline state of health. Intraoperative cultures grew C. acnes. Analysis of the surface of the plate demonstrated significant corrosion, and the crystal structure seen on SEM suggested a strong alloy that is prone to corrosion. Analysis of the cross section with EDS demonstrated an alloy containing 94.9% iron, 1.7% aluminum, 1.2% chromium, and 1.1% manganese.

CONCLUSION

The Lane plate was introduced around 1907 by Sir William Arbuthnot Lane, a British surgeon, and was one of the first widely used devices for the plating of fractures. Given that this patient was likely one of the last to be treated with a Lane plate, this may be the final opportunity for such a retrieval analysis. .

Copyright © The Iowa Orthopaedic Journal 2023.