Excessive Sugar Consumption May Be a Difficult Habit to Break: A View From the Brain and Body.

The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism. 2015;100(6):2239-47

Plain language summary

It is widely known that people eat to relieve stress. Rodent studies have shown that sugar consumption switches off activity in the networks that mediate the stress induced hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) autonomic nervous system. This study aimed to compare the effects of consuming drinks, sweetened with either sucrose or aspartame, on cortisol responses induced by stress. The researchers found that sucrose consumption was associated reduced stress induced cortisol, and a trend towards lower cortisol. Aspartame did not have the same effect. The Montreal Imaging Stress Task (MIST) was used to map areas of the brain associated with stress. It was found that sugar consumption caused a diminished response to MIST after two weeks of sucrose consumption, and cortisol was elevated after two weeks of aspartame. The study concluded that brain negative feedback pathways are affected by sugar, and consequently may make stressed individuals more reliant or addicted to sugar. In turn, this increases the likelihood of obesity and its associated chronic diseases.

Abstract

CONTEXT Sugar overconsumption and chronic stress are growing health concerns because they both may increase the risk for obesity and its related diseases. Rodent studies suggest that sugar consumption may activate a glucocorticoid-metabolic-brain-negative feedback pathway, which may turn off the stress response and thereby reinforce habitual sugar overconsumption. OBJECTIVE The objective of the study was to test our hypothesized glucocorticoid-metabolic-brain model in women consuming beverages sweetened with either aspartame of sucrose. DESIGN This was a parallel-arm, double-masked diet intervention study. SETTING The study was conducted at the University of California, Davis, Clinical and Translational Science Center's Clinical Research Center and the University of California, Davis, Medical Center Imaging Research Center. PARTICIPANTS Nineteen women (age range 18-40 y) with a body mass index (range 20-34 kg/m(2)) who were a subgroup from a National Institutes of Health-funded investigation of 188 participants assigned to eight experimental groups. INTERVENTION The intervention consisted of sucrose- or aspartame-sweetened beverage consumption three times per day for 2 weeks. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Salivary cortisol and regional brain responses to the Montreal Imaging Stress Task were measured. RESULTS Compared with aspartame, sucrose consumption was associated with significantly higher activity in the left hippocampus (P = .001). Sucrose, but not aspartame, consumption associated with reduced (P = .024) stress-induced cortisol. The sucrose group also had a lower reactivity to naltrexone, significantly (P = .041) lower nausea, and a trend (P = .080) toward lower cortisol. CONCLUSION These experimental findings support a metabolic-brain-negative feedback pathway that is affected by sugar and may make some people under stress more hooked on sugar and possibly more vulnerable to obesity and its related conditions.

Lifestyle medicine

Fundamental Clinical Imbalances : Hormonal ; Neurological
Patient Centred Factors : Mediators/Cortisol
Environmental Inputs : Diet
Personal Lifestyle Factors : Nutrition
Functional Laboratory Testing : Saliva
Bioactive Substances : Hydrocortisone ; Cortisol

Methodological quality

Allocation concealment : Yes

Metadata

Nutrition Evidence keywords : Sugar ; Women ; Addiction ; Chronicstress ; Sucrose ; Aspartame ; HPA ; Hypothalmus ; Pituitarygland ; Adrenalgland